If you’ve been following my recent posts exposing the results I’ve observed from a few of my submit button testing rounds, you’re sure to love this final post in the series.
I’m going to bring all of the elements together and show you the submit button that smashed my initial control. (And the exact HTML and CSS code for doing it yourself!)
To recap the other post in this series…
Give Them Another Reason to Click!
(Providing “secondary link feedback”, such as a color change, can help users know that your link or button is “clickable”.)
You need to give your visitors the finger!
(Make sure your buttons provide “primary link feedback” and change the cursor arrow into a pointing finger.)
Size Does Matter!
(Bigger buttons often produce bigger response rates.)
Well today we are going to put all of these pieces together to create what I like to call “The ULTIMATE Submit Button”!
Here is what I tested…
The Red Border Trick

I first noticed a border around a submit button about 4 years ago when I saw this on Google’s Adsense Log-in page:

Since that time I’ve tested several different variations and colors of borders around submit buttons and in most cases a red border converts best. (Although there are a few niches where I’ve found green or blue pulling slightly better.)
The Red to Green Trick

Following my principle of providing “secondary link feedback”. I decided to test a color change when the mouse hovers over the button.
Because in most western societies, we are trained from a young age that “red means stop” and “green means go”, using green for my secondary feedback was a logical choice. (I’ve tested several other colors as well, but green usually wins by a wide margin.)
Here are the results from the final submit button test round…
Red Border: 38.0% Opt-in rate.

Red Border, Green Roll Over: 41.6% Opt-in rate.

So…
Starting with a “standard” submit button, and simply by continually testing new ways to draw attention and “get the click”, we were able to move from a “control” opt-in rate of 28.4% to a 41.6% opt-in rate.
That represents a 46.5% improvement in response, by simply testing a small handful of the 18+ submit button test variables in my arsenal.
Even after 6,000+ tests, it never ceases to amaze and surprise me, how seemingly small changes can produce such huge impacts on conversion rates.
Now it’s time for you to stop reading… and START TESTING!
Oh… wait… I guess I did promise to show you the code for this trick, didn’t I?
Okay… Here it is:
CSS Code to go in your style sheets:
.submit {
border: 1px solid #000000;
background-color: #FFFFFF;
padding: 2px;
font-family: Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
font-weight: bold;
font-size: 12px;
cursor: default;
}
#submitpad {
padding: 5px;
background-color: #ff0000;
margin: 0px;
border-width: 3px;
border-color: #ff0000;
border-spacing: 0;
}
HTML code for your submit button area:
<table border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0">
<tr>
<td nowrap id="submitpad"
onMouseDown="this.style.backgroundColor='#009900'"
onMouseOver="this.style.backgroundColor='#009900'"
onMouseOut="this.style.backgroundColor='#ff0000'">
<span style="cursor:pointer;">
<input name="submit" type='submit' style="cursor:pointer; font-size: 16px;" value='Give Me My FREE Report Now! >>'/></span>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
There you have it! Everything you need to go out and test this trick on your own site.
Just remember, every niche and target audience responds a little bit different to each of these elements, so test each of these variables on your own sites and with your own traffic.
If a red boarder doesn’t do the trick, test green or blue.
If a big button helps a tiny bit, try an even bigger button. (Or better yet a FRIGGIN’ HUGE BUTTON!)
Have fun with this stuff…
Just keep testing!
Eric Graham,
“The Conversion Doctor”
P.S. ““ Want some help figuring out what (or how) to test on YOUR site? Then you might want to checkout my Conversion Booster Video Website Evaluation Service.
P.P.S. ““ UPDATE: I’ll be darn! Have a peek at what my good buddy Michel Fortin is testing right now on his Copy Doctor site…

His button was already BIG. But the primary (finger) and secondary (green) feedback looks new to me!
That right there is the critical difference between those who make millions online and those who struggle to survive… Quick, Decisive and MASSIVE action!
Like I said… Don’t just read this stuff. TEST IT!
About the Author
Eric Graham is a serial entrepreneur, author, speaker, copywriter and consultant. Enter your name and email address below to get notified when new response boosting tips, tested conversion strategies, updates, articles and videos are posted. You'll also get immediate access to a powerful 90 minute Conversion Boosting video as a free gift for signing up (and a lot more!)
And while you're here, go ahead and follow Eric on Twitter!
Claim Your FREE ConversionBoosting Video! Fill out the form below and you'll immediately receive (via email) full instructions on how to watch this powerful recording! |
Related posts:
- Submit Button Usability Split Test Results: Size DOES Matter!
- What in the Heck is “Secondary Link Feedback”?! (And how can it help you sell more?)
- The Conversion Doctor’s Blog Is “Not Helpful”?
- Link to Free “Conversion Rate Optimization” Webinar Recording (only for a limited time…)
- Free Webinar Recording Replay (For a few days only!)


Claim Your FREE Conversion






Eric Graham says Size Matters!…
For Submit Buttons That Is…. I refer to Eric’s blog a lot – that’s because I like the testing he regularly shares with his readers… it’s very valuable stuff! I mentioned his results on split testing Submit Button Size before…….
Eric
I completely agree that a red button draws attention quickly and if a hover can turn it into green, the prospect will really feel like clicking and make the red turn green (we love to see that happening on the traffic signal, don’t we?).
Spot on, mate!
Thanks Arun.
Eric, great post.
I especially like the traffic light analogy. It’s a relatively simple thing, but you’re right of course. We’re all conditioned to pay attention to red and we’re all conditioned that green means go. I think it’s the same all round the world, isn’t it?
Very, very good post.
Hi Eric,
I’ve been using “large” buttons for quite a while, but just started using the pointer/hand cursor. I’m amazed at the increased response you’ve attained by something as simple as this — I hope to do the same.
I put together a simple “button creator” on my “utilities” page which you are free to use . . . I started with the code you supplied and added some enhancements like the ability to specify text color and bold text. It also allows you to have multi-line-text buttons . . . I’ve tested with MSIE 7 and Firefox 2 and everything seems to work . . . I hope you enjoy it!
http://www.paulgalloway.com/utilities/high-response-buttons/
Best,
Paul
P.S. Have any of your tests used multi-line-text buttons?
[...] 4. Bigger subscribe button. After reading the Conversion Doctor and seeing his results with a large button and double user feedback, I couldn’t resist. However.. up till this point I’ve been using AWeber’s dynamic form serving to track conversions, so obviously I can’t have both. [...]
[...] [Stephen] Well really what you’re seeing is me trying to get Paypal to let me use a text link instead of an image. If there’s an easier way to do it, I didn’t find it. And I never got test results for a plain text link because I found Eric Graham’s posts on the Ultimate Submit Button. [...]
Thank you, I am going to add this to my sales letters.
Hi Eric,
Great meeting you in Atlanta. These buttons are “The Bomb”.
I will definitely use them on all my sites.
Thanks for the tip man!
Your Friend,
Steve
Get my List Building Tips newsletter
Today at: http://www.list-pros.com
Hi Eric – thanks for this tip. I tried it and using Google Website Optimizer I saw a statistically significant lift of 44.6%.
That’s vs my control which was a graphical submit button that I thought looked ok from the start.
Not any more.
This red/green button is now my control on my home page, but needs some fixing for IE I’ve been told.
I owe you a cold Canadian beer for this one
Got any more tips for us?
More Than 123% Increase in Opt-Ins…
Last month I ran a split-test of two opt-in forms. These were “hover” forms I quickly created in my aweber account. One of them offered a free eBook and the other one offered nothing. It’s no shock that the one offering the free …
[...] The ULTIMATE Submit Button REVEALED! Putting all the Pieces Together… | The Conversion Doctor … The submit button that smashed all controls. (tags: advice tips HTML CSS forms conversion usability) [...]
[...] Eric Graham tested 18 different versions of submit buttons and to find the ultimate submit button. [...]
Using html code instead of the javascript in aweber doesn’t let me track my conversions in aweber. So I guess I have to rely on google analytics and I can’t do split testing. Is there a tracking program anyone recommends to overcome this?
[...] The ULTIMATE Submit Button REVEALED! Putting all the Pieces Together. [...]
Hey, thanks for providing that code. I just was wondering how I can get it to work with my click bank purchase URL and to be centered on the page. It is going to the left for some reason, although I add it to the center in my program.
Also, can I make the text on it BOLD?
Thanks!!
Nelson
http://www.wealth-conscious.com
[...] for brave designers. Some of them are very thought-provoking, some eyebrow-raising, and some downright terrifying to the designer’s [...]
[...] The Ultimate Submit Button [...]
[...] Re: Perry Belcher Reveals his Button Eric Graham, the Conversion Doctor, was the one I first learn from about some of these tweaks. Here’s a blog post with more goodies from him The ULTIMATE Submit Button REVEALED! Putting all the Pieces Together… | The Conversion Doctor … [...]
[...] an increase in response of 35 to 320% over any other buy button tested. In his blog post titled ‘The ULTIMATE Submit Button REVEALED! Putting all the Pieces Together?’ Eric Graham (The Copy Doctor) revealed that using roll over effects on a button can increase [...]
[...] not good if you want to make money from the list! Lastly, I’d recommend testing using this button: The ULTIMATE Submit Button REVEALED! Putting all the Pieces Together? | The Conversion Doctor Blog In every split test I’ve run, this button outperforms any other. What also helps is "eye [...]
I just added Eric’s Ultimate Submit Button to my site (http://www.golfaid.com)and its worked great – thanks!
[...] The ULTIMATE Submit Button REVEALED! [...]
[...] [...]
[...] earlier today I noticed a trackback to one of my old blog posts “The Ultimate Submit Button” from the Warriors [...]
Hi David,
Found your site through the Warrior Forum directing to this post! Love your stuff, and I have just one question…
I pasted the code for this button into my page and it looks great in Firefox but the button width is too wide in IE.
Any ideas what the problem is with that?
(I was testing it in IE 7, and it basically overlaps other div tags and I can’t seem to resize the box or table at all??!??!)
[...] to convert higher than plain forms. Here’s an example of how web forms can effect conversion rates: The ULTIMATE Submit Button REVEALED! Putting all the Pieces Together… | The Conversion Doctor … And there’s a bug at least for me when I do try to create the new web forms and use the java code. [...]
[...] The ULTIMATE Submit Button REVEALED! [...]
[...] The ULTIMATE Submit Button REVEALED! [...]
[...] The ULTIMATE Submit Button REVEALED! [...]
I never cared much about learning CSS until I saw your details writeup and the power that these buttons could have. Thanks
Hey, Eric,
todate I thought that these fancy “submit” buttons are located only on the sites designed by professional web designers.
Today you made me a gift I was looking for months.
Thank you so much!
Great Stuff.
I am setting up a Thank You page with some bonuses. I was wanting to use the “ULTIMATE Submit Button” as the redirect link
I have the “button” on my webpage, but am unable to hyperlink from “button” to new URL.
What is the HTML code for this process?
Christopher Savage